SME Strategy 7 min Read

Clearing House vs. Payroll Software: Which is Better?

By SMEStack Compliance Editorial • General information, not tax or legal advice

With the SBSCH closing, many SMEs are weighing up whether to use a standalone clearing house or the integrated super features in their payroll software. Both have their merits.

Standalone Clearing Houses

Pros: Often free (if provided by your default fund), specialized support, and handles complex fund lists well.
Cons: Requires a separate login and manual file uploads (CSV/SAFF).

Integrated Payroll Super

Pros: One-click payments, no file handling, and automatic reconciliation with your bank feed.
Cons: Usually requires a paid subscription (e.g., Xero or MYOB) and can sometimes have higher "per-transaction" fees for small teams.

The Verdict

If you have a small, stable team, a free fund-based clearing house is often the most cost-effective choice. If you have high staff turnover or complex awards, the automation of integrated payroll is worth the investment. Regardless of your choice, our SBSCH Migrator can help you move your data into either system with ease.

Related guides